bigjohn

There is many a good tune played on an old fiddle.

  • Warning! Elderly Person Blogging

    elderly1.jpg

    Creative Commons License
    This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.

    t-blogger.jpg

    lion-2.jpg

  • Awarded by Terri. Click below for 'Island Writer'.

  • My Life and Times

    I was born in 1939 BC. That's 'Before Computers'. Luckily I survived the following events in my life, such as World War II, The London Blitz, Rationing, and worst of all... Archbishop Temple's School.

    me-poster.jpg

    me-r-book.jpg

    a-b-t-1.jpg

    During the mid 1950s I was enjoying Rock 'n' Roll and being a first generation teenager, when suddenly, just like Elvis, I found myself in uniform during 'The Cold War'...and then

    copy-me-rr.jpg

    me-w-badge.jpg

    wed-baby.jpg

    I became 'a family'. Which meant that I sort of missed the 'swinging sixties', but still managed to look a complete prat in the 70s, just like everyone else.

    copy-of-70s.jpg

    me-pit.jpg

    golf-dinner.jpg

    During the 'Thatcher Years' I lost my hair and a lot of people lost a good deal more. My career fluctuated to say the least as I was demoted, promoted, fired and hired a number of times, but still I managed to stagger on into a welcome retirement and to celebrate 50 years of happy marriage.
  • October 2008
    M T W T F S S
    « Sep   Nov »
     12345
    6789101112
    13141516171819
    20212223242526
    2728293031  
  • Meta

  • RSS Validated.

    valid-rss.png
  • Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 47 other followers

Not such a “Merry Monarch”.

Posted by Big John on October 8, 2008

I must say that I do enjoy watching a good historical drama on TV, and over the years there have been many; one of which was .. ‘The Six Wives of Henry VIII’ .. made in 1970 and starring Keith Michell who played a very believable King Henry; as did Richard Burton in ‘Anne of a Thousand Days’.

With this in mind I tuned in to ‘The Tudors’, which I quickly re-named .. ‘Royal Rumpy-Pumpy’.. Blimey ! I’ve heard of ‘History-Lite’, but this series takes ‘Ye Olde Pisse’ !

“OK !”, (as Henry exclaimed in one episode) so I found the programme entertaining and unintentionally funny in places, but why ‘sex-up’ history when the facts and characters are dramatic enough in themselves.

I’m sure that even as a young man Henry had ginger hair, a beard and was probably of a ‘stocky’ build. When Catherine of Aragon died during the time of his marriage to Anne Boleyn he was fortyfive years old, and yet he was depicted in the movie as a slim, black haired, clean-shaven twenty-something !

Among the many historical errors the most obvious are that Henry had two sisters (not one), Margaret and Mary. Margaret married the King of Scotland and Mary married the King of France, but as far as I know, there is no evidence that Mary ever killed her husband, and Henry Fitzroy (the king’s illegitimate son) was about eighteen when he died, not three. Cardinal Wolsey did not commit suicide, and the whole story line involving various Popes was confused to say the least.

In one episode I did notice that Anne Boleyn was riding in a carriage which did not exist at the time, but failed to spot the ‘tarmac’ and radiator covers that appeared in other scenes.

I have to confess that I am a bit puzzled by the title .. ‘The Tudors’ .. as there were quite a few of them, including six monarchs. We’ve already missed out on Henry VII and after two series we have only got as far as Henry VIII’s third wife.

I wonder if we will ever …

get to meet the rest of the family ? :???:

5 Responses to “Not such a “Merry Monarch”.”

  1. Chris said

    ‘The Tudors’ has always seemed a bit over-hyped, so I’ve steered clear of it. Yes, it might be entertainment rather than education, but still, accuracy does matter. The producers would have been better to omit things they didn’t want; making alterations such as you describe just makes the whole thing look like a joke.

    By the way, talking of inaccuracies, I couldn’t help noticing WordPress’s idea of a ‘possibly related post’ to this one. What the hell has HTTP Pipelining got to do with historical drama?

  2. Pamela said

    I’m so glad to read your opinion. I’m certain that neither of us are prudes, but I had called it soft porn in period costume, since the “plot” was so inaccurate that there really was nothing else left.

    Wasn’t the real Henry supposed to be 6′ 2″ too? Actor Jonathan Rhys Meyers appears to be a 5 ft 9 in (175 cm) shortarse.

    They describe the series as “historical fiction”, but changing the facts so much only creates confusion and misinformation.

  3. Big John said

    Nice to hear from you, Pamela. Sorry that your comment was held up in my spam queue. Enjoyed your ‘Historical Hopscotch’. I’m not sure about Henry’s height, but I’ve seen his armour (including cod-piece), and he was a pretty big bloke in more ways than one. :lol:

  4. Darlene said

    I really hate it when the producers of a ‘so called’ historical drama take liberties with the facts. So many people get their history this way (lazy intellectually) that they think the inaccuracies are true. The one drama that I thought stayed closer to the truth was the John Adams series.

  5. I too have misgivings when films and TV series take liberties with facts. The excuse of “dramatic necessity” is a cop-out as far as I am concerned.

    The only good I hope comes out of it is that some of the people who watch will be intrigued enough to go off and read a genuine history and perhaps discover how interesting and how much fun real history can be.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 47 other followers

%d bloggers like this: